www.walkerlawhouston.com/blog/mutual-combat-in-texas-domestic-violence-cases-when-both-parties-are-at-fault

Common Legal Defenses in Domestic Violence Cases

Being charged with domestic violence in Texas is frightening — and the stakes are high. A conviction can affect your freedom, job, family, gun rights, and immigration status. But being charged is not the same as being convicted. You still have rights, and with the right defense strategy, you may be able to avoid jail, clear your name, or protect your record from long-term consequences.

This guide provides a tactical overview of the most effective legal defenses in domestic violence cases in Texas. Whether you're fighting false accusations, arguing self-defense, or negotiating a plea deal, knowing your options is the first step toward protecting your future.

Understanding the Prosecutor's Burden of Proof

Before diving into defense strategies, remember: the prosecution must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that you:

• Intentionally, knowingly, or recklessly caused bodily injury
• Harmed someone with whom you share a domestic relationship (spouse, dating partner, roommate, co-parent, etc.)

This means they must prove both what happened and why it happened — including your state of mind (known legally as mens rea).

Your defense begins by challenging one or both of those elements. Let's explore how attorneys do that.

Self-Defense: When You Had to Protect Yourself

In some domestic violence cases, the accused was actually the victim — forced to act in self-defense.

In Self-Defense in Domestic Violence Cases, we explain how Texas law allows the use of reasonable force to protect yourself if you believe you're in imminent danger. Your attorney may argue that:

• You were being physically threatened or attacked
• You used only the amount of force necessary to stop the threat
• You did not initiate the altercation

This strategy is especially effective when supported by bodycam footage, witness testimony, or your own injuries.

Mutual Combat: When Both People Were at Fault

Sometimes, both parties engage in physical conduct during a heated argument. If so, your lawyer may raise the defense of mutual combat.

In Mutual Combat: When Both Parties Are at Fault, we discuss how Texas law can treat certain domestic altercations as consensual physical encounters, especially if:

• Both people were physically aggressive
• No serious injuries occurred
• There’s a history of high-conflict behavior between both parties

This defense doesn’t excuse violence — but it can reduce charges, weaken the prosecution’s case, or help avoid a family violence finding.

False Allegations and Fabricated Evidence

Unfortunately, not every accusation is truthful. False claims are sometimes made to:

• Get revenge after a breakup
• Gain leverage in a custody dispute
• Avoid being charged as the primary aggressor

In False Allegations and Fabricated Evidence, we outline how attorneys investigate:

• Inconsistent statements
• Motive to lie
• Fabricated injuries or property damage
• Witness accounts or digital evidence that contradict the accusation

When the accuser’s story doesn’t hold up, your lawyer can push for dismissal, reduced charges, or a not-guilty verdict.

Lack of Intent or Accidental Injury

Texas law requires that you intended to cause harm — or acted recklessly. But what if the injury was an accident?

In Lack of Intent or Accidental Injury Defense, we explore how defense attorneys challenge the State’s claim of intent by showing:

• The incident was accidental (e.g., bumping into someone during an argument)
• There was no force, threat, or reckless behavior
• The accuser misinterpreted a defensive or accidental act as aggression

This strategy is especially useful when injuries are minor or inconsistent with violent behavior.

Challenging Witness Credibility

The State’s case often hinges on a single witness: the accuser. That makes credibility everything.

In Challenging Witness Credibility in Domestic Cases, we explain how attorneys:

• Highlight inconsistent statements
• Reveal bias or motive to lie
• Show contradictions between 911 calls, police interviews, and trial testimony
• Use text messages or social media to undermine the narrative

If the jury doesn’t believe the accuser, the State can’t meet its burden.

Improper Police Procedure and Unlawful Arrests

Police must follow the law too. If they don’t, your rights may have been violated.

In Improper Police Procedure and Unlawful Arrests, we cover how attorneys challenge:

• Warrantless entry into your home
• Miranda violations
• False or misleading police reports
• Arrests without probable cause

Successful pretrial motions based on these violations can lead to suppressed evidence — or case dismissal.

Using Character Evidence and Background as a Defense

Your clean record, stable employment, or reputation for non-violence can support your case.

In Using Character Evidence and Background as a Defense, we explain how defense attorneys present:

• Letters from employers, clergy, or community leaders
• Proof of parenting, military service, or counseling
• Evidence of the accuser’s aggressive behavior or prior false reports (when admissible)

This strategy can humanize you, reduce penalties, and help prevent a family violence finding.

Lack of Evidence: Can the Case Be Dismissed?

The State needs more than an accusation to win in court.

In Lack of Evidence: Can the Case Be Dismissed?, we discuss how attorneys push for dismissal when:

• There are no injuries
• The accuser won’t testify
• Evidence is inconsistent or missing

By showing the State has no realistic path to conviction, your attorney may convince the prosecutor to drop or reduce the case.

Plea Bargaining: Negotiating for Better Outcomes

Sometimes, the best defense is a smart resolution.

In Plea Bargaining in Domestic Violence Cases, we walk through how attorneys negotiate:

• Reduced charges (e.g., from Class A to Class C)
• Deferred adjudication (no conviction)
• No family violence finding
• Time served instead of probation

Every case is different — and a skilled attorney can structure a plea that protects your job, family, and record.

Getting Charges Dismissed Pre-Trial: Motion Practice

Filing legal motions before trial can lead to early dismissal or a stronger negotiating position.

In Getting Charges Dismissed Pre-Trial: Motion Practice Explained, we explore:

• Motions to suppress evidence
• Motions to dismiss for lack of probable cause
• Motions to exclude prior statements (Crawford challenges)
• Motions in limine to block unfair or irrelevant evidence

Early, aggressive motion practice is often the best tool for avoiding trial altogether.

Final Thoughts: Build Your Defense Now — Don’t Wait

If you’ve been charged with domestic violence in Texas, you don’t have to accept a conviction or plead guilty just because you were arrested. The law gives you the right to defend yourself — and there are dozens of proven strategies to reduce or eliminate the charges.

At Walker Law Office, attorney Mekisha Walker defends clients throughout Harris, Fort Bend, Galveston, and Brazoria Counties. As a former prosecutor, she understands how the State builds its case — and how to break it apart. Whether you’re fighting false accusations, bad police work, or an overzealous DA, she will build the strongest defense possible.

Call (713) 228-2611 or visit https://www.walkerlawhouston.com/contact to speak with a lawyer near you today.

‍